2021-22 Season
- Dirty Rotten Scoundrels
- An Adult Evening of Shel Silverstein
- Frankenstein in Love
2020-21 Season
- A Midsummer Night’s Dream
- The Thanksgiving Play
- God of Carnage
- The Pirates of Penzance
- The Last Five Years
2019-20 Season
- The Brain From Planet X
- She Kills Monsters
- Lasso of Truth
2018-19 Season
- Man of La Mancha
- Hamlet
- Santaland Diaries
- Silent Sky
- Fun Home
2017-18 Season
- The Hunchback of Notre Dame
- We Are Pussy Riot
- The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane
- Sondheim on Sondheim
2016-17 Season
- Next To Normal
- I’ve Heard That Song Before
- The Metromaniacs
- Mary Poppins – The Broadway Musical
2015-16 Season
- Standing On Ceremony
- A Christmas Story
- Gidion's Knot
- Murder Ballad
- Pride & Prejudice
2014-15 Season
- On the Verge
- White Christmas
- Working
- A Flea in Her Ear
2013-2014 Season
- The Amish Project
- BatBoy
- Shakespeare Shakespeare
- Les Miserables
2012-2013 Season
- The Last Five Years
- Mauritius
2011-2012 Season
- Phantom of the Opera
- The Liar
- Legally Blonde
- Spring Awakening
- Xanadu
2010-2011 Season
- The Drowsy Chaperone
- Love's Labour's Lost
- The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
2009-2010 Season
- Light in the Piazza
- The Three Musketeers
- Altar Boyz
2008-2009 Season
- Fiddler on the Roof
- Eurydice
- Forbidden Broadway
2007-2008 Season
- Miss Saigon
- Smell of the Kill
- tick, tick...BOOM!
2006-2007 Season
- Urinetown
- Stop Kiss
- The Mikado
2005-2006 Season
- Disney's Beauty and the Beast
- Twentieth Century
- As You Like It
- Creating a Playhouse
- Sylvia
- Plaza Suite
2004-2005 Season
- The Rocky Horror Show
- The Cripple from Inishmaan
- The Syringa Tree
- A Night at the Opera
2003-2004 Season
- 110 in the Shade
- A Doll's House
- The Guys
2002-2003 Season
- How to Succeed In Business without Really Trying
- The Bungler
- The Laramie Project
2001-2002 Season
- A Little Night Music
- Shakespeare's R & J
- Fuddy Meers